The Turkish president’s currying favor with Kurdish political parties could be a way to consolidate his hold on power further.
After World War I, Turkish general Mustafa Kemal, who had defeated the Allies at the Battle of Gallipoli in 1915, faced a formidable problem. The Treaty of Sèvres had partitioned Turkey, and the United Kingdom, France, Greece, and Italy had occupied it.
In May 1919, the Ottoman government dispatched Kemal to oversee the disbandment of its army in Anatolia under the treaty. He instead used the opportunity to organize resistance and begin the war for Turkish independence. As a result, foreign forces were driven from Turkey, culminating in the Lausanne Treaty in 1923, which established the borders of modern Turkey.
Mustafa Kemal (later known as Atatürk, “the father of the Turks”) faced the task of creating a national identity from the remnants of the Ottoman Empire. However, his secular reforms, for example, the abolition of the caliphate and Sharia law, were met with resistance and led to the Sheikh Said rebellion in 1925 and incipient Kurdish nationalism. There was also the Dersim massacre from 1937–1938.
A demand for a separate Kurdish state came in 1984 with the armed rebellion led by Abdullah Öcalan and the Marxist-Leninist Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), which led to the displacement of some 1–3 million Kurds and more than 40,000 killed. Öcalan was captured in 1999.
In 2005, in a keynote speech held in Diyarbakır, the main city in Turkey’s Kurdish southeast, then-Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoǧan reached out to the Kurdish diaspora and acknowledged Turkey had a Kurdish problem.
Behind the scenes, in the “Oslo process,” which took place between 2008 and 2011, a ceasefire was brokered in 2013. At the end of February 2015, the Justice and Development Party (AKP) government and the pro-Kurdish HDP (Peoples’ Democracy Party) negotiated a 10-point peace plan, the Dolmabahçe Agreement, which paved the way for a settlement.
However, at a party meeting the following month, HDP leader Selahattin Demirtaş declared three times that they would not make Erdoǧan president. After the HDP’s success in the parliamentary elections, where it gained 80 of the parliament’s (then) 550 seats and the AKP lost its majority, Erdoǧan turned his back on the agreement.
In July, in a bait-and-switch deal, Erdoǧan offered US President Barack Obama access to the Incirlik air base as he reignited the war against the Kurds, which led to widespread destruction and loss of life.
Michael Ray Richardson Dies: Banned NBA Player Was 70
Michael Ray Richardson Dies: Banned NBA Player Was 70
Sponsored | Blavity
After Istanbul’s popular mayor, Ekrem Imamoǧlu, was prevented from running in the 2023 presidential election, Erdoǧan won again. The Republican People’s Party’s (CHP) candidate, Kemal Kılıçdaroǧlu, helped. However, with the CHP’s success in the 2024 local elections under new leader Özgür Özel, Erdoǧan can see the writing on the wall. The government has cracked down on 41 CHP municipalities, arresting or suspending mayors.
Imamoǧlu’s arrest in March last year on extensive charges and the court order in May replacing Özgür Özel with Kılıçdaroǧlu are preemptive measures to ensure Erdoǧan’s reelection. However, in July Özel formed the New Party (YP), which with its 91 seats (out of the Turkish parliament’s 600) is Turkey’s second-largest party and a threat to Erdoǧan’s hold on power. Consequently, steps have been taken to remove Özel’s parliamentary immunity as a prelude to prosecution.
In October 2024, a major step towards reconciliation with Turkey’s Kurds was taken when Devlet Bahçeli, the leader of the National Movement Party (MHP), the AKP’s partner in the People’s Alliance, crossed the parliament floor to shake hands with the leader of the Peoples’ Equality and Democracy Party (DEM), the HDP’s successor.
Delegations met with Abdullah Öcalan on Imralı prison island, and Bahçeli called on Öcalan to urge the PKK to lay down its arms, which Öcalan did. In July last year in Sulaymaniyah in Iraq’s Kurdistan, 30 PKK fighters laid down their arms in a symbolic ceremony, which Erdoǧan hailed as the dawn of “a terror-free Turkey.”
Last August, a parliamentary commission was formed to oversee the disarmament of the PKK. Chairman of the AKP’s parliamentary group Abdullah Güler said that 18 meetings were held, including MIT (National Intelligence Organization) and the Foreign Affairs, Interior, Justice, and National Defense ministries. They worked closely with the MHP and the DEM, and on August 5 the “Strengthening National Solidarity and Social Integration” bill (known as the framework law) was submitted to parliament.
Initially, 367 deputies signed the bill, and three days later the Justice Committee approved it after 18 hours of debate. On August 10, the General Assembly passed the bill with 467 votes in favor, mainly from the AKP, MHP, and DEM.
In effect, the 12 articles provide a conditional amnesty for a number of members of the PKK. First, the National Security Council has to determine that the PKK has ceased its activities and that its weapons and ammunition have been handed over.
Those who have committed the crime of intentional killing or crimes committed before June 2005 that carry a sentence of life or aggravated life imprisonment are excluded, which means Öcalan and the PKK’s senior leadership. Others will receive a probationary period. A government board and a parliamentary commission will monitor the process.
Özgür Özel, leader of the New Party (YP), criticized the bill for failing to address the root causes of the Kurdish problem. While he voted for the bill “to pave the way for Turkey’s future,” he left it to party members to decide. 54 YP members voted against.
Mansur Yavaş, the mayor of Ankara, who has been targeted as a rival to Erdoǧan, wrote that true peace cannot be established by passing a law alone. The foundations of peace are justice, the rule of law, trust, and social consensus. Turkey’s greatest problem is that citizens’ trust in the state and in justice has been severely damaged.
Müsavat Dervişoğlu, chairman of IYI (Good) Party, a breakaway party from MHP that voted unanimously against the bill, cut to the chase. He argued that the main purpose of the bill was to secure Erdoǧan’s lifelong presidency.
He is not alone with that suspicion. Al-Monitor has pointed out that the AKP and MHP together have 323 seats, but with DEM (56 seats) they will pass the 360-seat threshold, enabling them to hold a snap election. If successful, this will guarantee Erdoǧan a third term. However, the fact that several DEM mayors have been arrested and replaced with trustees since the 2024 local elections must make DEM support for Erdoǧan unpalatable.
On the other hand, Numan Kurtulmuş, the speaker of the Turkish parliament, which has gone into recess until October 1, now believes there is a basis for making a new constitution, “a civilian constitution,” to replace the 1982 constitution passed after the military coup in 1980. If 400 deputies vote “yes,” this is possible.
There is a paradox. Although Erdoǧan claims the new law will lead to a terror-free Turkey, since 2015, 394,090 have been convicted because of Turkey’s anti-terrorism laws, and the number is rising. Turkey has systematically cracked down on lawyers and, in particular, human rights defenders.
Last year, Erdoǧan said a terror-free Turkey would take the Turkish economy to new heights. This might be news to millions of Turkish families impoverished by economic mismanagement and crippling inflation, who nonetheless have to deal with the further erosion of Turkish democracy.
About the Author: Robert Ellis
Robert Ellis is a Turkey analyst and commentator. He is also an international advisor at RIEAS (Research Institute for European and American Studies) in Athens. He is a regular commentator on Turkish affairs in the Danish and international press. Earlier, he served as an advisor to the Turkey Assessment Group in the European Parliament and as a senior fellow at the Gatestone Institute in New York.
SOURCE:https://nationalinterest.org/blog/middle-east-watch/recep-tayyip-erdogans-kurdish-gambit
CSS Forum – Join Now
